The Italian Cafe

Pin It PIN IT!

WHEW. What a day it has already been. My feelings can be summed up in just this one e-card.

Some days, I just want to scream, go on a random punchy spree and jump out the window. And, yes, you guessed it! Today is one of those days. Just a few more days and then I’m free to my own devices. Free to cook, eat, write and pet my little furry man’s face all day, which has been proven to reduce stress and homicidal tendencies.

However, my post today is not to rant. In fact, it’s to do a bit of a restaurant review! Seriously, how cool would it be to get paid to eat, drink and review? I’m pretty sure that’d be a dream job. New York Times, I’m for hire. I’m witty, snarky and sarcastic, love to eat and drink and can be pretty darn honest. And, I love eating. Did I mention that?

Anyway, for my birthday dinner, my darling husband and I went to the Italian Cafè last night, a local Italian eatery less than a mile from our house. The allure is definitely not on the outward appearance. In fact, it looks like the kind of place the mob visits and holds their “secret” meetings in the back. With that, I asked for a seat not near the windows.

[image via]

 What I’ve learned through being a “foodie” is that you can’t judge a book by it’s cover. Some of the best food in the world is served out of dives and shabby looking diners. So, we went in and were pleasantly surprised by the interior. It had a vintage, old Italian feel and smelled like fresh marinara sauce simmering on the stove top.


But, I’m not here to discuss decor. I’m here to talk food! When we got the menu, we were shocked to see how long it’s been around, since 1978! In this tough economic climate, it’s hard for restaurants to survive a year, better yet 30. If it’s been around that long, there’s got to be a reason for that, right?

I was starving (partly because I hadn’t eaten since noon and partly because of the tantalizing aroma engulfing  my nose) so we immediately dug into the bread basket. They had two varieties, a softer, sweeter bread and a traditional Italian.

My favorite was the sweeter kind! It almost tasted like Hawaiian sweet bread. Yum. We polished off the bread basket as we waited for our appetizer, the insalata caprese.

The mozzarella was SO fresh. As much as I love the stuff I buy at the store, this stuff tasted like it was made to order. I also loved the balsamic dressing on the salad. It was tangier than most but still had a really strong flavor. We then moved on to the dinner menu. As per our roommates suggestion, E ordered the asiago chicken with cream sauce and I ordered the shrimp scampi. The salads that came with the meal were immediately brought out. Sadly, they weren’t anything to write home about. Simple mixed greens with restaurant ranch.

By the time the entrees arrived, I was already full, but you can’t possibly pass up the entree. I mean, it’s the main attraction! Plus, they both looked absolutely incredible.

Asiago Chicken with cream sauce and asparagus

Shrimp scampi

Elliot immediately dug right into his, barely looking up for a breath. What he did share was amazing. The cream sauce wasn’t too heavy, but still very decadent and the chicken was cooked perfectly. I can definitely see why my roommates loved it! My scampi was good, but not as good as the chicken. What I loved most was how big and juicy the shrimp was.

The flavors were great I was just mainly a little dissapointed in the sauce. For a wine butter sauce, I didn’t taste much of anything. It just seemed a bit oily. However, the sauteed mushrooms were amazing and the shrimp was incredibly fresh.

Since I was stuffed way past my comfort point (let’s just say I had a bit of a Santa thing going on over my skinny jeans) I asked for a box and a cappuccino. I’ve really gotten into enjoying coffee after a big meal. It makes digestion easier and gives me a reason to slow down. E and I both eat really fast. It’s something we’ve done for a while and usually leaves us rushing out of restaurants. So, enjoying a warm cup of coffee lets me savour the experience and enjoy my time out.

Overall, I was impressed. I loved the ambiance, the food was great (especially the chicken and mozzarella) and the prices were really good. With it being so close and so affordable, it’s definitely a place we’ll visit again. With so many Italian chains out there whose menus are clichè and overpriced, it’s refreshing to be able to get an authentic, fresh meal and fabulous service without a gimmick. I mean, isn’t that what you want when you go out to eat?

Visit: The Italian Cafè, 7161 Lee Highway, Falls Church, Va 22042. Call (703) 241-1829 for reservations!

What is your favorite local resaturant? Why do you like it so much?

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Comments

  1. Posted by Lauren on
    Wednesday, December 7th, 2011
    the cafe sounds amazing!! Yumm :)
  2. Posted by Gretchen on
    Wednesday, December 7th, 2011
    I've driven past that place 100 times, but never gone in! I'll definitely make a point to try it out now -- I agree that I was always a little skeeved out by the way it looks, but I should know better by now!

    Also, LOL: "Free to cook, eat, write and pet my little furry man’s face all day" -- it took me a second to realize you weren't talking about Elliot. BAHAHA.
    • Posted by Claire Gallam10 on
      Wednesday, December 7th, 2011
      Bahahahagha. He is also furry! And definitely go in! The mob won't get you!
  3. Posted by Jessica Trimble on
    Wednesday, December 7th, 2011
    That asiago chicken dish sounds amazing, glad you had a wonderful birthday dinner!
  4. Posted by Kiri W. on
    Wednesday, December 7th, 2011
    Oh wow, that insalata caprese looks to die for! Nothing beats fresh, homemade mozzarella :) God, now I miss Europe. Can't wait to go home for the holidays!
    My favorite local restaurant is a small Thai place. It's just this great, tiny place with incredibly flavorful food and great staff - I even proposed there. It was their first ever proposal, and they didn't mind one bot it was two women. On the contrary, they helped my set up the last station of the surprise-treasure hunt I sent my then-girlfriend on, they all stood in the back watching anxiously and cheered when she said yes and brought out huge amounts of extra-special food. We still always get huge smiles and more food than usual :)
    • Posted by Claire Gallam10 on
      Wednesday, December 7th, 2011
      Omg what a cute story!!!!!!
  5. Posted by Jennifer on
    Wednesday, December 7th, 2011
    Looks insanely delicious!!
  6. Posted by Jessica Lynn on
    Wednesday, December 7th, 2011
    Goodness gracious, I miss American Italian food. I forgot what a big difference it is. I love it out here, don't get me wrong, but sometimes things are a little on the bland side and I like nice, bold flavors.

    Fun fact: people have told me here that if you order a cappuccino after 10 or 11 am it's looked down upon. Milk is supposed to only be consumed in the morning. That being said, we still order cappuccinos after our meals.
  7. Posted by Grubarazzi on
    Wednesday, December 7th, 2011
    Right in my ole neck of the woods! 
  8. Posted by Bake Your Day on
    Wednesday, December 7th, 2011
    I want that pasta...it looks so comforting and delicious!
  9. Posted by Meredith Wise on
    Thursday, December 8th, 2011
    Glad my suggestion of the Asiago Chicken was good! I loved it. This place and Meat in a Box are 2 things we're really going to miss about this area! And PS - I can tell you that the chocolate cake at the Italian Cafe is stellar :)